Insurer | Telephone Number | Direct Writer* or Contact Agent** |
21st Century Group- 21st Century Centennial Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- 21st Century Assurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- 21st Century Pinnacle Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
| 1-800-807-9458 (21st Century Centennial)1-800-241-1188 (21st Century Assurance, 21st Century Pinnacle) | Direct |
Allstate Group - Allstate New Jersey Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Allstate New Jersey Property and Casualty Insurance Company
| 1-866-222-4586 | Agent |
American Commerce Insurance Company | 1-800-222-2114 | Agent |
American Family Group- Midvale Indemnity Company
| 1-844-241-7972 (toll-free) | Direct |
American International Group - AIG Property Casualty Company
- Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania
| 1-866-856-6858 | Agent |
Amica Group - Amica Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- Amica Mutual Insurance Company
| 1-800-242-6422 | Direct |
Bristol West Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan | 1-888-888-0080 | Agent %3rnational Group- AIG Property Casualty Company
- Insurance Company of the State of Pennsylvania
| 1-866-856-6858 | Agent |
Amica Group - Amica Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- Amica Mutual Insurance Company
| 1-800-242-6422 | Direct |
Bristol West Foremost Insurance Company Grand Rapids, Michigan | 1-888-888-0080 | Agent |
California Casualty & Fire Insurance Company (membership group for educators, firefighters, nurses and state police) | 1-866-680-5143 | Direct |
California State Auto Group - CSAA Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company of NJ (not accepting any new business)
- CSAA Affinity Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- CSAA General Insurance Company
| 1-800-542-9544 (CSAA & CSAA Affinity)1-888-222-0094 (CSAA General) | Direct (CSAA) Agent (CSAA Affinity) Direct and Agent (CSAA General)(AAA/CSAA) (CSAA General) |
CHUBB Group- Chubb Insurance Company of NJ
- Atlantic Employers Insurance Company
- Bankers Standard Insurance Company
| 1-866-324-82221-800-352-4462 | Agent |
Cincinnati Insurance Company | 1-888-242-8811 | Agent |
Citizens United Reciprocal Exchange (CURE) | 1-800-535-2873 | Direct |
Electric Insurance Company | 1-800-342-5342 | Direct |
Encompass Group- Encompass Property and Casualty Insurance Company of NJ
- Encompass Insurance Company of NJ (not accepting any new business)
| 1-800-262-5238 | Agent |
Esurance Insurance Company of New Jersey | 1-800-378-7262 | Agent |
Farm Family Group- United Farm Family Insurance Company (membership)
| 1-800-843-32761-888-382-6722 | Agent |
Farmers Insurance Group - Mid-Century Insurance Company (not accepting any new business except Basic policies)
- Farmers Insurance Exchange
| 1-800-327-6377 | Agent |
Fitchburg Mutual Insurance Company | 1-800-688-1825 | Agent |
Founders Insurance Company | 717-234-4941 1-800-388-4764 | Agent |
GEICO Group- Government Employees Insurance Company
- GEICO Casualty Company (not accepting any new business)
- GEICO Indemnity Company
| 1-800-861-8380 | Direct |
Hanover Insurance Company | 1-800-257-5720 | Agent |
Harleysville Group - Harleysville Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Harleysville Preferred Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Harleysville Worcester Insurance Company
| 1-800-523-6344 | Agent |
Hartford Group- Hartford Insurance Company of the Midwest
(membership company for AARP) - Hartford Underwriters Insurance Company
(membership company for AARP, not writing new business) - Hartford Fire Insurance Company
| 1-800-843-7824 (AARP)1-800-460-9783 (Non-AARP) | Direct (AARP) (Non-AARP)
|
IDS Property Casualty Insurance Company | 1-800-535-2001 (Customer Service) | Direct |
Liberty Mutual Group- Liberty Mutual Fire Insurance Company (not accepting any new business except Basic policies)
- Liberty Mutual Mid-Atlantic Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- LM Insurance Corporation
- Wausau Underwriters Insurance Company (Affinity Groups only)
| 1-800-526-1547 1-800-524-9400 (Sales) 1-800-225-8285 (Service) | Agent Direct |
Mercury Indemnity Company of America | 1-800-987-2032 | Agent |
MetLife Auto and Home - Metropolitan Group P&C Insurance Company (not accepting any new business except Basic Policy)
- Metropolitan Direct P&C Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- Metropolitan Casualty Insurance Company
- Metropolitan General Insurance Company
| 1-800-888-2308 (Met Group and Met Direct) 1-800-422-4272 (Met P&C, Met Casualty, and Met General) | Direct (Met Group P&C, Met Casualty, and Met General) Agent (Met Direct P&C and Met P&C) |
Metromile Insurance Company | 1-888-244-1702 | Direct |
MIC General Insurance Corporation | 1-800-325-1190 | Agent |
Nationwide Group- Nationwide Mutual Insurance Company
- Crestbrook Insurance Company
| 1-877-669-6877 1-855-473-6517 | Direct Agent |
New Jersey Manufacturers Group- NJ Manufacturers Insurance Co. (membership company for certain affinity groups)
- NJ Re-Insurance Company (membership company for certain affinity groups)
- NJ Indemnity Insurance Company (for assigned risk business only)
| 609-883-1300 1-800-232-6600 | Direct |
New Jersey Skylands Insurance Association | 1-866-279-7688 | Agent |
Personal Service Insurance Company | 1-800-954-2442 | Agent |
Plymouth Rock- High Point Property and Casualty Insurance Company
- High Point Safety and Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Teachers Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey (membership company for employees of educational institutions)
- Palisades Safety & Insurance Association
- Palisades Insurance Company
- Twin Lights Insurance Company (for assigned risk business only)
| 1-866-INSURANCE (High Point)1-866-658-3224 (Teachers)1-877-725-6423 (Palisades)908-219-5050 (Twin Lights)
| Agent and Direct |
Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange (PURE) | 1-888-814-7873 | Agent |
Progressive Group - Progressive Freedom Insurance Company (not accepting any new business)
- Progressive Garden State Insurance Company
- Drive New Jersey Insurance Company
| 1-888-287-3449 NJ | Direct (Progressive Freedom & Progressive Garden State) Agent (Drive New Jersey) |
Selective Auto Insurance Company of New Jersey | 973-948-3000 1-800-777-9656 | Agent |
State Farm Group- State Farm Guaranty Insurance Company
- State Farm Indemnity Company
| 1-800-STATEFARM (1-800-782-8332) | Agent |
Travelers Group- St. Paul Protective Insurance Company
- Fidelity & Guaranty Insurance Underwriters, Inc. (not accepting any new business)
| 1-888-695-46251-800-692-68371-800-526-6260 | Agent |
USAA Group (membership group for military personnel) |